Comments (0)The American male is broken and the only way to fix him is to redefine what makes him a success, said Rabbi Shmuley Boteach in his new book, titled, appropriately enough, “The Broken American Male and How to Fix Him” (St. Martin’s Press).
The problem? According to Rabbi Boteach, the American male is made to feel like a failure. Rather than taking pride in his accomplishments, he is always in competition with those around him to the point where he feels he cannot keep up.
“You’re trained to look behind you to see who’s gaining on you, and sideways to see who’s caught up to you,” said the rabbi. “The dehumanization of the American male is destroying him. He’s made to feel like he’s a not a human being, he’s a human ‘doing,’ and he’s only valued for what he produces.”
Rabbi Boteach first wrote about the topic in a column three years ago. After syndication carried it to about 70 newspapers, he received more than 5,000 e-mails telling him that he had struck a chord.
When filming his cable TV show on TLC, “Shalom in the Home,” the subject of the dysfunctional male kept reappearing as he traveled from home to home across America. Finally, he decided to put together his thoughts on the subject.
But while men are the focus of Rabbi Boteach’s book, women don’t escape unscathed. Originally, he had thought to name the book “The Broken American Male and the Inadequate American Female.”
More than half of the divorces in America are initiated by women, he said, because their husbands have become intolerable. When men see themselves as losers, he went on, they view a woman who would marry them as twice a loser, and women don’t want to be married to men who feel that way.
“The broken American male, through his own state of brokenness, creates a feeling in women that they’re inadequate,” he said. “He comes home, he turns on the TV, he doesn’t talk. He’s not passionate. So you start blaming yourself. Your reaction becomes, ‘It must be me.’”
Rather than turning to their wives and families, the American male has a slew of other escapes, from sports to alcohol to television.
“Men don’t follow sports, they’re fanatical about sports,” Rabbi Boteach said. “The reason is if you feel like a failure, you try to live vicariously through your team.”
So how do we fix the problem? The solution begins at home with the next generation.
“We have to raise our boys to stress their emotions more,” Rabbi Boteach said. “We are much tougher on our sons in the belief that the world is going to be tougher on them and we don’t show them their emotions matter.”
Young boys should be given confidence that they have special gifts that only they can contribute to the world, he said.
The next step is to change what drives a man. If a man lives to work, he becomes burned out or overly focused on his work to the exclusion of his family.
To spur this change in focus, Rabbi Boteach has created a new definition of success by rearranging a man’s priorities.
Five factors should define a man’s success, he said. In order of importance, they are:
• His role as a husband;
• His role as a father;
• His role as a member of the community;
• Spirituality; and
• Professional success.
This list of priorities will restore balance in men, he said.
“We have to stop giving men a career and start giving them a calling,” the rabbi said.
A career is very self-focused, he explained. Focusing so much on advancing one’s own situation instills fear and insecurity and makes a man self-absorbed. He is always looking to compete with others for the next raise or promotion.
A calling, however, focuses a man on maximizing his potential for his own betterment, rather than trying to get ahead of others.
“A calling gives you a unique sense of purpose,” said Rabbi Boteach.
Josh Lipowsky is assistant editor of The Jewish Standard.