Voices: False Accusations of Anti-Semitism Hurt Jews More Than You Realize


As Americans of conscience, many of us are deeply troubled by the hyperpartisan tone that seems to color almost every news story and cycle. The sensationalism that is so often present within our nation’s discourse undermines our collective ability to assimilate information and reach well-reasoned conclusions. At times, the only voices that we hear are the loudest and most outrageous.

If this were not challenging enough, we also live in times where mass shootings are becoming more common and bold displays of xenophobic hatred are increasing in communities across our great country. It is against this backdrop that any new allegation of bigotry, prejudice and hatred is cast.

Therefore it was with frustration and deep upset that I learned a letter sent by Rep. Tom Emmer, R-Minn., has been characterized as anti-Semitic by some local Jewish leaders in Minnesota, whose charges were amplified by an item in the Jewish Telegraphic Agency.

The fundraising letter states in part that “news of impactful, real progress on turning our nation around was undercut by biased media … funded by deep-pocketed far-left billionaires George Soros, Tom Steyer and Michael Bloomberg. These left-wing radicals essentially BOUGHT control of Congress for the Democrats.”

Because two of the three people named in the letter are Jewish — and, presumably, because Steyer’s father is Jewish and at times he has identified as such — Carin Mrotz, the executive director of St. Paul-based Jewish Community Action, told American Jewish World News that the letter contains “pretty classic anti-Semitism.”

As someone who knows Emmer well, I feel that nothing could be further from the truth.

In spring 2016, I led a weeklong mission to Israel with Emmer and a delegation of Jewish community leaders from his home state of Minnesota. As a then-freshman Congressman, Emmer made travel to Israel a top priority for his first term in office.
Throughout our trip, Emmer demonstrated a nuanced understanding of the geopolitical tensions that contour Israel’s relations with her neighbors. When we met with the director-general of the Foreign Ministry, mayors of towns and members of Knesset, he showed a genuine concern for Israel’s security. At Yad Vashem, he shed tears with us over the wholesale murder of the majority of European Jewry.

Emmer also demonstrated a deep respect for the Jewish people’s ancestral ties to Israel and to the Torah. When we met with Rabbi David Lau, Emmer and the Ashkenazi chief rabbi of Israel shared a warm dialogue about the critical importance of protecting the right of American Jewish children to a strong, robust and affordable Jewish education.

These are not the actions of an anti-Semite. Emmer has shown himself to be a true friend of the Jewish community and of the U.S.-Israel relationship. This cannot be said about every member of Congress and, sadly, not even about every member
of Minnesota’s congressional delegation.

Indeed, Democrat Rep. Ilhan Omar is encouraging the boycott, divestment and sanctioning of the State of Israel. Rather than would-be, implied anti-Semitism, this is the very definition of modern anti-Semitism.

In the words of Rabbi Jonathan Sacks, former chief rabbi of Britain, “In the middle ages, Jews were hated because of their religion. In the nineteenth and early twentieth century, they were hated because of their race. In the twenty-first century, they are hated because of their nation-state. Anti-Zionism is the new anti-Semitism.”

Falsely accusing someone of anti-Semitism is just as dangerous as not calling out anti-Semitism. By falsely flagging conduct as anti-Semitic, we lose our ability to stay focused on combating the real threats of anti-Semitism — and we lose our credibility to define and identify them.

If all conduct critical of any Jew is anti-Semitic, then the term loses its teeth and becomes just another meaningless phrase.
While I personally may have preferred a different syntax within the fundraising letter, I find any suggestion that Emmer harbors attitudes of anti-Semitism to be profoundly offensive. His record of pro-Israel and pro-Jewish legislation and his deep personal friendship with members across the full spectrum of the Jewish community simply do not support that contention.

By raising the specter of anti-Semitism against our community’s friends, we alienate our closest allies. Especially in the dangerous times in which we live, our community can ill afford to take its friends for granted.

Rabbi Hersel D. Lutch is the COO of Bender Strategies, LLC. He has served in multiple leadership capacities within the American and International Jewish community, including COO (North America) of Aish HaTorah. A native Bostonian, Lutch lives in Baltimore with his wife and three children.


  1. Hershel Lutch’s argument falls flat. He claims that because Rep. Tom Emmer is “pro-Israel” he should be given a free pass for engaging in a classic anti-Semitic trope of the money-bags Jew. Nonsense. White supremacist and neo-Nazi icon – and could there be more a parade example of an anti-Semite than a contemporary neo-Nazi?- Richard Spencer has extolled Israel as a model for the Aryan homeland he hopes to establish in the United States. Indeed, in October 2017, he told an audience at the University of Florida that “the most important & perhaps most revolutionary ethno-state…one that I turn to for guidance…is the Jewish state of Israel.” Which makes Spencer “pro-Israel” !


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here